Of them I would think the Zacapa and the Appleton align best with my tastes. I find the subtleties of Zacapa can be pretty quickly overwhelmed by a strong cigar, but it works well with them anyway because it is sweet. I like the rums of Jamaica as a rule with medium bodied cigars, so I'd think the Appleton paired well with most smokes you tried. Never tried the Tommy stuff but then I don't wear the shirts either!